Updated 07 August 2014

Calls to stop commercial surrogacy in Thailand

A case where a Thai woman who carried twins for an Australian couple was left caring for a baby with Down syndrome has sparked controversy in both countries.


Authorities in Thailand are to inspect all the clinics in the country offering surrogacy services to see if they are operating within the law after a Thai woman who carried twins for an Australian couple was left caring for a baby with Down syndrome.

The case has caused controversy in both Thailand and Australia, bringing calls to prohibit commercial surrogacy in the Southeast Asian country to end a lucrative trade.

Nationwide inspection

In Australia, the case has sparked calls for an overhaul of surrogacy laws to cut the number of couples traveling abroad to find surrogates.

The nationwide inspection in Thailand would start next week, Lieutenant Colonel Chatmongkol Wasinamorn of the police consumer protection division said.

"We'll check whether they were licensed for surrogacies and whether they were done correctly by doctors," he told Reuters. "Representatives from the Medical Council will go with us to check whether those surrogate cases followed the medical code."

Read: Surrogacy: the truth

Commercial surrogacy is against the Medical Council of Thailand's code of conduct. Surrogacy is permitted if blood relatives of the couple are the surrogates, although exceptions are permitted if no suitable surrogate is available.

The council is an independent agency that supervises doctors and the medical system but needs support from the police and other state agencies to help deal with any violations of its code.

Boy left behind

The surrogate mother, Pattaramon Janbua, 21, has said she agreed to a fee of 350,000 baht (±R111 000) to carry the twins for the Australian couple. They took the girl she delivered back home with them but left the boy, Gammy, behind.

Now seven months old, he is being treated for a lung infection in a hospital east of Bangkok. He also needs surgery for a congenital heart condition, according to media reports.

A friend of the couple, who have not spoken publicly, told a newspaper in Australia the experience had been "absolutely devastating".

The couple, from the small town of Bunbury in Western Australia, denied that they requested an abortion when they found out Gammy had Down Syndrome and denied abandoning the baby, the Bunbury Mail reported the friend had said.

Read: Medical abortions are safe: study

The twins were born prematurely and the couple were told Gammy would not survive, according to the report.

Heart and lung conditions

"They prayed for Gammy to survive but were told by doctors that he was too sick, not because of the Down Syndrome but because of his heart and lung conditions and infection," the newspaper quoted the friend as saying.

An official at Australia's Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade said Gammy's case was "sad, complex and difficult" and the Australian government was working with Thai authorities to clarify its legal position on surrogacy, which was unclear.

Vichien Chavalit, permanent secretary of Thailand's Ministry of Social Development and Human Security, said this week there were no laws governing surrogacy in Thailand. A law had been drafted but not yet submitted to parliament, he said.

The surrogate mother, Pattaramon, said her doctors, the surrogacy agency and the baby's parents knew he was disabled when she was four months pregnant but did not inform her until the seventh month when the agency asked her – at the parents' request – to abort the disabled fetus.

Pattaramon told Reuters Television that, as a Buddhist, she refused the abortion on religious grounds.

Abortion proposal

The agency manager who had been in charge of the case confirmed the Australian couple were informed before Pattaramon.

"They knew that they had twins and that one of the children had Down Syndrome," the manager, who gave her name as Joy, told Reuters Television. "We told the Australian couple first because we believed that the decision should be made by the biological parents."

She declined to give her full name and said she left the agency several months ago. She would not comment on the abortion proposal or other matters.

Read: Abortion: religion plays role

Pattaramon told a news conference she had never spoken directly to the Australian couple, although she told Reuters later that she had met them in Thailand.

"We met three times," she said in a telephone interview. "We speak different languages so we couldn't discuss much."

Read more:

Indian surrogate mothers tell their tales
Surrogacy may lead to exploitation
Abortions for sale

Image: Newborn with Down syndrome from Shutterstock




Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

Gut health »

Can't lose weight? Blame it on your gut

Our nutrition experts weigh in on why gut health is such an important factor in weight loss, on World Obesity Day.

Sleep better »

Yes, there is such a thing as too much sleep

A new study confirms that too little sleep can impair your brain, but interestingly, too much sleep is also a problem.