Updated 23 October 2015

Functional foods not for all

Functional foods can benefit certain sectors of the population who may not derive the nutrients they need from their daily diet, but they may also pose a risk, researchers say.

They may also pose a risk of overdose of certain vitamins and minerals, according to a new report from The Netherlands.

The report from the Dutch National Institute for Public Health and the Environment reviews food and dietary trends in The Netherlands and their effects on public health, with a view to maximising the impact of government campaigns and research programmes.

Dietary habits the key

The key take-home message is that addressing unhealthy diets would have a major impact on public health. An unhealthy diet (such as insufficient consumption of fish, fruit and vegetables and too many trans and saturated fatty acids) is said to reduce the average life expectancy of Dutch 40 year-olds by 1,2 years, and obesity by 0,8 years.

“Taking into account not just deaths but also years spent living with serious disability, unhealthy dietary habits together cause as much health loss as does smoking,” it said.

The report has been praised by Herman Koëter, acting executive director of the European Food Safety Authority, who said it will be “a leading document in Europe and probably beyond when it comes to making risk-benefit analyses of our food and diets”.

In the chapter dedicated to functional foods and dietary supplements, however, it questions whether these kinds of products can have a health benefit for the general population, or whether some of them may, in fact, present more of a risk.

“In general, healthy consumers who adhere to the Guidelines of Good Nutrition will have no need for functional foods or health products, the consumption of which will result in little or no health gain for these consumers,” wrote the authors.

Risk groups identified

But they did identify the elderly as being particularly at risk because reduced appetite may lead to insufficient food and nutrient intake; vegans and others whose intake of animal products is low; heavy drinkers who have a less varied eating pattern, and whose intestines may be restricted from absorption of vitamin B1 by alcohol; the elderly and ethnic women who may risk vitamin D deficiency through rarely going outdoors; and those who avoid certain foods due to allergy or adherence to a weight-loss regime.

However, in cases where the health claims behind products have been backed by clinical research, it questions whether the results of such research can really be extrapolated to everyday life.

In a trial situation, dose and usage is carefully controlled, but in an everyday situation consumers may not abide closely by the instructions. Moreover, there are considerable differences in individuals’ lifestyles, for example in the amount of exercise they do, which could be measured or controlled in a clinical environment.

The biggest caveat the report gives is that bioactive substances that occur naturally in foods and herbal ingredients that have been used for many years may not be as safe in large doses as they are generally presumed to be.

Present situation

At present, vitamin and mineral-enriched foods marketed in The Netherlands are subject to the Commodities Decree on the Addition of Micronutrients to Foods, and must first be registered with the Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority.

EU legislation to harmonise fortification levels across member states is currently in progress, with a positive vote in Parliament recorded two weeks ago.

It has been several years since a systematic review of functional food and supplement consumption has been carried out across the entire Dutch population (the last survey being in 1997/8, when almost seven percent of the total Dutch population was reported to consume one or more enriched food product).

The enrichment of products with vitamins and minerals was only authorised in 1996, so it is likely that intake of vitamins and minerals has increased “due to the emergence and burgeoning popularity of functional foods and dietary supplements”.

The chapter concludes that it is “extremely important that functional foods and health products are included in future food consumption surveys” , since otherwise it is difficult to assess the health effects at population level.

Read more:

Scientists create food that reduces hunger

Mediterranean diet keeps seniors' mind healthier

Don't let your feelings fool your belly


Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

Your hearing »

Are you going deaf or do you just need to unblock your ears? 4 foods that can improve your hearing

Healthy eating may protect your hearing

Watching what you eat can improve the quality of your hearing and reduce your risk of hearing loss.

Quit smoking »

Tougher anti-tobacco laws in the pipeline Bad news, smokers: It's going to be more inconvenient to smoke

This is why many SA smokers quit – Health24 survey

After running our survey for several weeks, the results are in – and they reveal interesting information about smoking and tobacco use in South Africa.