15 April 2014

Cranky babies get to watch more TV

Babies who have difficulties regulating their emotions, calming themselves down and sleeping well end up watching significantly more media.


Fussy and demanding babies are likely to spend slightly more time plopped in front of a TV or computer screen when they're toddlers than are "easier" babies, new research finds.

It's not clear just what this finding means. Parents could be trying to get a break from their high-maintenance children, or the kids could be naturally drawn to screens. The study didn't explore what the kids were watching, so it's not clear if those extra minutes of "screen time" – an average of nine minutes a day – were harmful, beneficial or somewhere in between.

But the main finding is still intriguing, said study lead author Dr Jenny Radesky, a fellow with the department of paediatrics at Boston Medical Centre. "The children who really had difficulties regulating their emotions, calming themselves down and sleeping well wound up watching significantly more media when they were toddlers," she said.

Read: Mother's love soothes difficult tots

Radesky launched the study to better understand young children, like her own, who can be fussy and difficult. "I know how stressful that can be as a parenting experience for new parents," she said.

It may not be temporary, Radesky said. High-maintenance kids can grow up into high-maintenance adults who have a hard time coping with life and its challenges, she said.

Fussy and irritable

But it's not clear how much being fussy and irritable – at age 2 or age 52 – has to do with genes and how much has to do with nurture and other factors. And being demanding isn't necessarily a universally bad trait for an adult. It could, for example, make someone a fine CEO.

Radesky also wanted to explore the issue of "screen time" – sitting in front of a computer monitor or TV screen.

She and her colleagues pulled statistics from surveys of parents of 7,450 kids who were born in 2001 and tracked for a couple of years. At the age of 9 months, 39 percent were deemed to have moderate or severe problems with so-called "self-regulation", suggesting they're generally fussier, moodier and more irritable and demanding than the other kids.

These children looked at screens an average of 2 hours and 29 minutes a day, according to their parents, nine minutes more than the average level of "screen time" for the other kids.

Read: Babies are tyrants

Some of the parents might not have accurately reported how much screen time their kids got, so the numbers could be wrong. The study is also a bit out of date when it comes to the evolution of screen time: Parents were surveyed before the dawn of iPads and smartphones.

Interacting with people

In general, researchers frown on exposing kids of any age to a lot of screen time. The American Academy of Paediatrics recommends that children under 2 not watch any TV "or other entertainment media" because they learn best by interacting with people.

Of course, many parents don't follow those guidelines because they want to occupy their children so they can work, do chores or simply relax.

In a second study in the same journal, researchers at MassGeneral Hospital for Children and the Harvard School of Public Health found an association between more TV viewing/having a TV in the bedroom in early childhood and shorter sleep, especially among minority children.

Read: 5 facts on your baby’s brain

What's next for research? Radesky said a study to be released soon will shed light on what kids are actually watching when they get "screen time". The current study doesn't examine the content of programming, meaning there's no way to know if it's educational.

"I really want to know if this is a good thing," she said. "Are parents getting a break from their more intense children by putting [them] in front of educational media? Or is it worse because they're missing out on more educational activities?"

The study was published online and appears in the journal Paediatrics.

Read more:

How diet influences your baby’s life
How to stimulate your baby
Battling with baby blues




Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

Gut health »

Can't lose weight? Blame it on your gut

Our nutrition experts weigh in on why gut health is such an important factor in weight loss, on World Obesity Day.

Sleep better »

Yes, there is such a thing as too much sleep

A new study confirms that too little sleep can impair your brain, but interestingly, too much sleep is also a problem.