20 April 2015

Tanzanian woman wins landmark case over botched caesarian

A Tanzanian woman has won a landmark law suit against a hospital after a botched caesarian section left her unable to have any more children.


A woman left unable to have children after a defective caesarian section operation in Tanzania has won a landmark case against a local hospital whose surgeon left a piece of cloth inside her.

Mwamini Adam and her husband filed a lawsuit at the high court in western Tabora region against Urambo District Council's hospital four years ago, demanding 500 million Tanzanian Shillings ($265,000) for physical and emotional distress.

Adam, 37, accused Jacob Kamanda, a gynaecologist and obstetrician at the district hospital, of professional negligence and misconduct after he left a piece of cloth in her stomach after performing a caesarian section operation.

She told the court her condition deteriorated within days of the operation on January 6, 2011, in which her baby survived.

"I was very ill and constantly discharging pus. It was a terrible blow to my family since I could no longer engage in my daily activities," she said.

She said the defective operation meant she can no longer give birth because doctors performing a life-saving corrective operation decided to remove her uterus.

Read: Common c-section concerns

Childbirth dangerous for rural Tanzanian women

Pregnancy and childbirth are among the biggest dangers faced by rural women in Tanzania due to a shortage of qualified doctors and lack of quality healthcare and maternity services.

Tanzania is one of a list of African nations that have the world's highest rates of maternal mortality. For every 100,000 live births, 454 women die of childbirth-related complications, according to UNICEF data.

Delivering the verdict this week, High Court Judge Amir Mruma said the court was convinced Adam suffered significantly due to negligence by one of the hospital's doctors and ordered hospital owner, Urambo District Council, to pay compensation.

Lawyers for Adam said this was the first time in Tanzania that a court had ruled in favor of a woman whose life was put in danger by defective surgery related to childbirth.

The judge ruled the council pay 25 million Tanzanian Shillings with accumulated interest to Adam and her husband and also cover the costs of the law suit.

($1 = 1,885.0000 Tanzanian shillings)

Read more:

Many women dying during childbirth in Ebola-hit countries

C-sections tied to lower incontinence risk

Women with a fear of labour endure longer childbirth

Image: Detail shot of steralized surgery instruments with a hand grabbing a tool from Shutterstock




Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

Smoking and weight gain »

Don't think that you're off the hook if you smoke cigars 10 smoking myths people still believe

Quitting smoking? Even a little exercise can help you stay slim

Best results in limiting weight gain after quitting smoking were found in women who engaged in 150 minutes of moderate intensity activity per week.