14 December 2012

Therapy, not drugs for psychosis

Young adults at very high risk of psychotic illness should receive talk therapy rather than anti-psychotic drugs as an initial treatment, a new study suggests.


Young adults at very high risk of psychotic illness should receive talk therapy rather than anti-psychotic drugs as an initial treatment, a new study suggests.

The results might ease fears about over treating people who have warning signs of psychosis but not full-blown disease, but the study was small and so the findings are not conclusive.

"This shows it's quite safe and reasonably effective to offer supportive psychosocial care to these patients," said Dr Patrick McGorry, an author of the study. There is "no evidence to suggest that anti-psychotic medications are needed in first-line" treatment, he said.

How the study was done

The clinical trial included 115 clients of a Melbourne, Australia, clinic for young people deemed to be at "ultra-high risk" for a psychotic disorder.

The study was open to individuals between the ages of 14 and 30 who met at least one of three criteria: having low-level psychotic symptoms, having had previous brief episodes of psychotic symptoms that went away on their own, or having a close relative with a psychotic disorder along with low mental functioning during the past year.

The study compared three regimens: talk therapy focused on reducing depression symptoms and stress while building coping skills plus a low dose of the anti-psychotic risperidone, or talk therapy plus a placebo pill, or therapy emphasising social and emotional support plus a placebo.

The goal was to see how many participants in each group progressed to full-blown psychosis.

After a year, there was no notable difference between the groups, although about 37% of the participants dropped out during the study. Dr McGorry said if the trial had included more people, significant differences between the groups might have emerged.

What the study found

Researchers have been working to identify people at risk of developing psychotic disorders. "The importance of detecting early signs and symptoms of a serious mental illness is not controversial," said Dr Matcheri Keshavan, a psychiatrist at Harvard Medical School. "But the best way of treating or preventing it remains controversial."

Dr McGorry, a professor at the Center for Youth Mental Health at The University of Melbourne, said that only about 36% of high-risk individuals will likely progress to psychosis within three years - so there's concern about treating everyone at risk with drugs, which come with side effects.

Another concern is that individuals will carry the label of mental illness unnecessarily.

Dr McGorry said the "vast majority" of the at-risk young adults in the study, most of them university-age, met the requirement for some kind of mental illness. That's why all the participants received some level of care, even if it was just basic emotional and social support and coping skills.

The rates of progression to full-blown psychosis - which ranged from about 10% to about 22% - were lower in all three groups than in previous studies.

It's not clear why, but Dr McGorry said it's possible that more participants will develop psychosis after the end of the 12-month study period. Many of them were also taking antidepressants, which may have eased psychotic symptoms.

As with many trials, most participants showed poor adherence to the medications used, which may have influenced the results, the authors note.

Dr McGorry was also an author of a 2010 study that found fish oil supplements might prevent psychosis in the same type of at-risk individuals. That research continues, he said.

Going forward, "what is needed is some way of finding predictive biomarkers that can tell who might be at the highest risk," said Dr Keshavan. "We need to understand their brains."

Dr McGorry and some of his co-authors have served as consultants or received research funding from pharmaceutical companies. One of them, Janssen-Cilag, which developed risperidone, partially funded the study.

(Reuters Health, December 2012)

Read More:

Anger can make mental illness worse

Brain analysis can help predict psychosis

Marijuana use triggers psychosis


Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

Looking younger »

Can maple leaves help you look younger?

New research has found that maple leaf extract can help you look years younger.

Killer foods »

Wild mushrooms a 'silent killer'

Health practitioners are warning people to stay away from wild mushrooms.