11 April 2014

More high school compliance with concussion guidelines

Concussions are often caused by a blow to the head, frequently in collision sports, and increasing numbers of high school athletes are complying with recommended guidelines.


High school athletes who suffer from concussions are complying more with the recommended return-to-play guidelines, according to new research.

Compliance was tracked from 2005 through 2013, using a database of high school sports-related injuries, said Dr Mark Riederer, a clinical fellow in primary care sports medicine at Children's Hospital Colorado. Compliance began to improve, especially around 2008, he said.

"In 2007 we had just above 50% of athletes noncompliant," he said. "In 2012-2013, it looked like 20%. We think that's excellent."

Compliance improvement

A concussion is any brain injury that upsets normal functioning. Concussions are often caused by a blow to the head, frequently in collision sports such as football or ice hockey, according to the American Academy of Paediatrics.

Riederer was due to present the study findings this week at the annual meeting of the American Society for Sports Medicine in New Orleans. Studies presented at medical meetings are typically viewed as preliminary until published in a peer-reviewed journal.

He obtained the data from a national compilation of sports-related injuries reported by US high schools. He looked to see if the athletes complied with a set of commonly used guidelines known as the Zurich return-to-play guidelines.

For the study, the athletes were considered compliant if they waited to return to play six or more days after their symptoms resolved.

Read: Sports concussions: myths and facts

The improvement in compliance, Riederer said, can probably be traced to many factors. These include increased awareness from parents, athletes, coaches and doctors of the importance of treating concussions, as well as the increase in concussion laws spelling out what should be done when an athlete suffers a concussion.

More parents and athletes are being educated before sports participation, he said, including facts about the risks of a second concussion without enough recovery time. All 50 states and the District of Columbia now have some kind of state law on youth concussions, protecting athletes from returning to play too soon, he said.

Evaluation and clearance

In some states, parents get a handout explaining the seriousness of a concussion and what should be done. "Some states require a signature on file that both parents and athletes have received this," he said.

Children who have a concussion should be evaluated by a health care professional and cleared before returning to sports, according to Riederer and other experts.

The new study does demonstrate that athletes are getting better at complying with the guidelines, said Dr John Kuluz, director of traumatic brain injury and rehabilitation at Miami Children's Hospital, who reviewed the findings.

However, he said, the survey did not include athletes in non-school programs, so it may not be an accurate reflection.

More awareness of symptoms

Many students play in leagues, he said, and on other non-school-related teams. "I suspect, if you look at all concussions, noncompliance [with guidelines] is a lot higher," he said.

In another presentation at the meeting, researchers from Rutgers University in New Jersey also suggested that there's room for improvement. They surveyed 79 freshman and 89 junior athletes from an NCAA Division I university about concussions. While 73% of the freshmen said it was acceptable to "tough it out" during a game if you suspect you have a concussion, 85% of juniors did.

More juniors than freshmen reported having symptoms of concussion. That may mean they have more concussions or they are more aware of the symptoms, the researchers said.

Whichever the implication, Kuluz said, the survey also indicates that there is room for improvement.

Read more:
New concussion guidelines tougher
Measuring footballers' risk of concussion

Teens fare worse with concussions


Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

Healthy gut »

IBS – 4 symptoms that extend beyond your stomach

When you think of IBS, symptoms that come to mind include diarrhoea, constipation and gas. However, there are other symptoms that extend beyond your stomach.

Sex health »

Do you feel sad after sex? This is why and what you can do about it

A new study published in the Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy has revealed that 41% of the men surveyed had felt sad after sex in the previous four weeks.