Updated 17 January 2018

Do early dental visits really prevent kids' cavities?

A new study suggests that early preventive dental care may actually increase children's need for cavity treatment later in life.

It has always been believed that early dental care will keep a child's teeth healthy and strong and parents were urged to make brushing, flossing and regular visits to the dentist a habit – but a recent study suggests otherwise. 

Children who start seeing the dentist before age two may not have a lower risk of cavities later on, the study suggests.

In fact, researchers found, youngsters who had early preventive dental care were more likely to need cavity treatment as they grew older, compared to other kids.

"It's a counterintuitive finding," said lead researcher Justin Blackburn. He's an assistant professor at the University of Alabama at Birmingham School of Public Health.

Not the dentist's fault

"We're not trying to say that dentists are somehow causing kids to have tooth decay," he stressed.

Nor do the findings mean that early dental care is useless, Blackburn said.

He acknowledged that there were limitations to the study. For one, it included only children in Alabama's Medicaid programme. So it's not clear whether the findings apply to US kids more generally, Blackburn said.

Still, the results question the conventional wisdom that babies' and toddlers' dental visits help ensure healthier teeth later.

Right now, groups including the American Academy of Paediatrics and American Dental Association suggest that children start dental care – whether from a dentist or paediatrician – by the age of 12 months.

Unclear benefits of early dental care

Yet there has been surprisingly little research looking at whether it actually benefits kids, Blackburn said. And a recent review of that research concluded that the evidence is "weak", he said.

"This is something we should keep studying, to make sure we're recommending what's right," Blackburn said.

The current study was published in JAMA Paediatrics.

The findings are based on nearly 20 000 children in Alabama's Medicaid programme. Medicaid is the publicly funded health care programme for low-income Americans. Blackburn's team used insurance claims records to track the children's dental visits from birth. The average follow-up time was almost four years.

Overall, one-quarter of the children received "preventative" dental care before the age of two. The researchers determined that by looking for particular medical codes in the Medicaid claims records.

It turned out that those children were actually more likely to need treatment for tooth decay over the next several years: Almost 21% did, versus 11% of other children – even though both groups of kids were similar in terms of demographics and their families' overall health care use.

An expert not involved in the study agreed that the findings don't mean that early dental care is somehow causing cavities.

Instead, some babies and toddlers who went for early visits may already have had signs of cavities, said Dr Peter Milgrom, a professor at the University of Washington School of Dentistry in Seattle.

In that case, their visits would not have been purely preventive.

"The problem is, the study used administrative data, which doesn't tell you about [the children's] clinical status," said Milgrom, who wrote an editorial published with the study.

What does preventive care involve?

According to Milgrom, the main recommended service is topical fluoride "varnish". But it's not actually clear how effective those products are, he said.

Plus, Milgrom added, "Children who already have high levels of tooth decay continue to get new decay even when the varnish is applied."

But preventive dental care should include more than topical fluoride, Milgrom stressed. Doctors should be giving parents advice on cavity prevention.

That boils down to two things, he said: Using fluoride toothpaste to brush young children's baby teeth, and being careful about their diets.

One of the most important things parents can do, Milgrom noted, is to limit sugar-sweetened juices and other drinks. And never let babies sleep with a bottle, he said. Even with milk or formula, that habit can promote so-called "baby bottle tooth decay".

It's not clear, Milgrom said, how often parents in this study were getting that kind of advice.

Tips from Health24's dentist

Dr Gerald Kaplan, Health24's dental expert, says your child’s first visit to the dentist is an important part of growing up. Here is some advice from Dr Kaplan about what to do and what not to do before your child’s first visit to the dentist:

Read More:

Scuba diving can put pressure on your teeth

Teething tips for babies from dental experts

More kids need dental sealants


Ask the Expert

Oral health expert

Dr Imraan Hoosen qualified from the Medical University of South Africa in 1997. Together with his partner, Dr Hoosen now runs a group of dental practices around Johannesburg (Lesedi Private Hospital, Highlands North Medical Centre , Brenthurst Clinic, Parklane Clinic, Simmonds Street Medical and Dental Centre, Soni Medical Centre- Newclare). Dr Hoosen can be contacted on 011 933 4096.

Still have a question?

Get free advice from our panel of experts

The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical exmanication, diagnosis and formal advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.

* You must accept our condition

Forum Rules