Lung cancer

Updated 28 August 2014

New kind of trial will speed cancer drug development

A new kind of clinical trial is about to change the way cancer drugs are studied, allowing them to brought to market more quickly and cheaply.

Scientists and drugmakers are pioneering a new kind of clinical trial that changes the way cancer drugs are studied, potentially cutting both the time and cost of bringing them to market.

Instead of testing one drug at a time, a novel lung cancer study will allow British researchers to test up to 14 drugs from AstraZeneca and Pfizer at the same time within one trial.

The aim is to quickly pinpoint medicines that can fight advanced lung cancer by targeting specific rare genetic mutations – and it upends the normal approach of putting a particular drug at the centre of a study.

Re-writing the rule book

Harpal Kumar, chief executive of charity Cancer Research UK, which is working on the 25-million-pound ($42-million) project with the two drugmakers, said the new approach would "re-write the rule book on how we do clinical trials".

"We are shifting the emphasis from designing a trial around a specific drug to designing it around selecting from a range of drugs for a specific patient," he told reporters.

The National Lung Matrix trial, which will open in a few months at centres across Britain, is part of a growing trend in cancer research to remodel the way new drugs are tested to keep up with the age of genomic medicine – fine-tuning treatments to the genetic profile of patients.

The US group Friends of Cancer Research said it was backing a similar multi-drug, multi-arm clinical trial to evaluate five experimental lung cancer drugs.

Because any single gene mutation behind a particular cancer can be extremely rare, perhaps affecting as few as 1 or 2% of patients, studying one drug at a time is extremely challenging.

Read: Gene mutations linked to fatal lung disease

The new trial offers a way around this by creating a protocol under which scientists can test patients' tumour samples for multiple gene faults and then assign them to an appropriate drug from among those in the trial for testing.

No more randomisation

Significantly, it does away with the idea of randomisation, where some patients are given a treatment and others get a "control" substance for comparison – traditionally the gold standard in drug testing.

Increasingly, researchers are questioning whether such randomisation makes sense in patients with incurable cancer if a certain treatment is genetically bound to work much better in some people than others.

Faster, smaller testing could shave years off the usual drug approval process. That also points to lower costs, although firms will be left with small markets from which to recoup investment.

"It's premature to talk about pricing but it will make drug development more cost-effective," said Menelas Pangalos, AstraZeneca's head of innovative medicines.

Mace Rothenberg, senior vice president at Pfizer Oncology, said: "It should be a more efficient process but it is for a more niche, focused group of patients."

Fast-tracking testing

The new trial in non-small cell lung cancer will use up to 12 experimental drugs from AstraZeneca, including two compounds designed to boost the immune system that will be given to patients who do not show one of 21 sets of gene faults.

Pfizer, meanwhile, is supplying Xalkori, which is approved for certain rare lung cancers and may also work in some even more unusual types, as well as the experimental drug palbociclib, which has shown promise in breast cancer.

Around 15 to 20 patients will be given each drug initially and promising medicines could be fast-tracked into larger-scale testing. Those that show no benefit will quickly be dropped.

Kumar said new medicines could be added to the existing trial as science advances, and he hopes other drug companies will join the programme in due course.

A successful programme in lung cancer could also lead to the concept being rolled out into testing drugs for other tumour types, he said.

Read more:
Lung cancer tumours often harmless
Tailored Treatment for Advanced Lung Cancer?

Lung cancer screening can save many


Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Ask the Expert

Cancer expert

CANSA’s purpose is to lead the fight against cancer in South Africa. Its mission is to be the preferred non-profit organisation that enables research, educates the public and provides support to all people affected by cancer. Questions are answered by CANSA’s Head of Health Professor Michael Herbst. For more information, visit

Still have a question?

Get free advice from our panel of experts

The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical exmanication, diagnosis and formal advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.

* You must accept our condition

Forum Rules