Share

Lung cancer tumours often harmless

accreditation
iStock
A provocative analysis suggests that lung cancer, the world's top cancer killer, isn't as deadly as doctors once thought, finding that almost 1 in 5 lung tumours detected on CT scans are probably so slow-growing that they would never cause problems.

These were not false-positives — suspicious results that turn out upon further testing not to be cancer. These were indeed cancerous tumours, but ones that caused no symptoms and were unlikely ever to become deadly, the researchers said.

Still, the results are not likely to change how doctors treat lung cancer.

Aggressive treatment

For one thing, the disease is usually diagnosed after symptoms develop, when tumours show up on an ordinary chest X-ray and are potentially life-threatening.

Also, doctors don't know yet how to determine which symptomless tumours found on CT scans might become dangerous, so they automatically treat the cancer aggressively.

The findings underscore the need to identify biological markers that would help doctors determine which tumours are harmless and which ones require treatment, said Dr Edward Patz, Jr., lead author and a radiologist at Duke University Medical Centre. He is among researchers working to do just that.

A leader of an influential government-appointed health panel agreed.

"Putting the word 'harmless' next to cancer is such a foreign concept to people," said Dr Michael LeFevre, co-chairman of the US Preventive Services Task Force.

Over diagnosis

The panel recently issued a draft proposal recommending annual CT scans for high-risk current and former heavy smokers – echoing advice from the American Cancer Society. A final recommendation is pending, but LeFevre said the panel had already assumed that screening might lead to over diagnosis.

"The more we bring public awareness of this, then the more informed decisions might be when people decide to screen or not," LeFevre said. He called the study "a very important contribution," but said doctors will face a challenge in trying to explain the results to patients.

In testimonials, patients often say lung cancer screening via CT scans cured them, but the study suggests that in many cases, "we cured them of a disease we didn't need to find in the first place," LeFevre said.

The study was published Monday in the journal JAMA Internal Medicine.

Worldwide, there are about 1.5 million lung cancer deaths annually.

Low-dose CT scans

The new study is an analysis of data from the National Lung Cancer Screening Trial – National Cancer Institute research involving 53 452 Americans at high risk for lung cancer who were followed for about six years.

Half of them got three annual low-dose CT scans – a type of X-ray that is much more sensitive than the ordinary variety – and half got three annual conventional chest X-rays. During six years of follow-up, 1089 lung cancers were diagnosed in CT scan patients, versus 969 in those who got chest X-rays.

That would suggest CT scans are finding many early cases of lung cancer that may never advance to the point where they could be spotted on an ordinary chest X-ray.

An earlier report on the study found that 320 patients would need to get CT screening to prevent one lung cancer death.

The new analysis suggests that for every 10 lives saved by CT lung cancer screening, almost 14 people will have been diagnosed with a lung cancer that would never have caused any harm, said Dr Len Lichtenfeld, the cancer society's deputy chief medical officer.

He said that is a higher rate of over diagnosis than he would have predicted, but that the study shows how much understanding of cancer has evolved. Decades ago, "every cancer was a bad cancer," he said.

Slow-growing cancers

Now it's known that certain cancers, including many prostate cancers, grow so slowly that they never need treatment.

The American College of Radiology said in statement Monday that the earlier study showed lung cancer screening significantly reduces lung cancer deaths in high-risk patients and that the benefit "significantly outweighs the comparatively modest rate of over diagnosis" found in the new analysis.

Low-dose CT scans are the only test shown to reduce lung cancer deaths in high-risk smokers, the radiology group said, adding, "Over diagnosis is an expected part of any screening program and does not alter these facts."

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
Who we choose to trust can have a profound impact on our lives. Join thousands of devoted South Africans who look to News24 to bring them news they can trust every day. As we celebrate 25 years, become a News24 subscriber as we strive to keep you informed, inspired and empowered.
Join News24 today
heading
description
username
Show Comments ()
Editorial feedback and complaints

Contact the public editor with feedback for our journalists, complaints, queries or suggestions about articles on News24.

LEARN MORE