Hearing management

Updated 11 December 2017

Idols: Are some people really tone-deaf?

Whenever it's Idols season the question comes up: can't the Wooden Mike contenders hear how terrible they sound? No, they can't, says a hearing expert.

Are some people really tone-deaf? asks a reader in the Hearing Management forum. Here's what the Widex Expert has to say:

This is a question that comes up whenever the Idols auditions roll around again. In the olden days, they used to say such a person has "a tin ear".

At a simple level, some people would call them "tone deaf", but it's actually more complex - some people cannot hear and distinguish different musical tones and notes, so their tuneless singing which sounds odd to us, sounds just as good to them as any singer's performance.

This is presumably why some of the very worst and most excruciatingly awful performers in the Idols auditions are most furious when the judges reject them. Either what they hear when they sing sounds better than what you hear, or it sounds just the same as what they hear when someone else sings the song properly.

But they may have the rhythm of the song correct, even though you might not notice that. Others cannot pick up the rhythm of a song to save their lives, even if they get the notes right.

Some don't get music at all, and could have congenital "Amusia" which is not at all funny, despite how it sounds.
Whether it can be helped is debatable. Some experts claim they can indeed remedy this with intensive training, but I find their claims unconvincing. It could be like trying to train a severely colour-blind person (who might see the world monochrome) to recognise colours. They might at best recognise different shades of grey in what they see, but would still have no idea of the colours you see.

The ones that could be helped would be those on the edges of the major disabilities --- some, I suspect, have never really learned how to listen to music, to recognise that there are different notes, rhythms, and so on, and they could probably learn to perform much better than they otherwise do.

(The Widex Hearing Expert Forum)

More: Visit the Hearing Management Centre

More on tone-deafness and the brain

Here is an extract from a Sapa story from 2009, in which an expert describes a study on tone-deafness and brain function:

People who are tone-deaf can't detect differences in musical pitch but usually have normal hearing and speech. Tone-deafness runs in families, and estimates of how many people have the problem range from 4% to 17%.

In the small study done in Boston, brain scans showed there was a difference in a particular brain circuit between those who were tone-deaf and those who weren't.

Among the tone-deaf, researchers discovered there were fewer connections between two areas of the brain that perceive and produce sounds.

The study's lead author, Psyche Loui, likened the connection to a highway between two islands in the brain.

In tone-deaf people, "there's less traffic on the highway," said Loui, who studies music and the brain at Harvard Medical School and is also a musician.



Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Ask the Expert

Hearing Expert

Minette Lister graduated with a Bachelor of Communication Pathology (Audiology) from the University of KwaZulu-Natal, Westville in 2015. Thereafter, she completed her compulsory year of community service at Phoenix Assessment and Therapy Centre in Durban. In 2017, Minette started working for Thompson and Hoffman Audiology Inc. She is passionate about working with children and adults to diagnose and manage hearing loss using state of the art technology. Minette offers hearing screening programmes for newborn and high-risk babies, as well as school-aged children, in order to decrease the incidence of late or unidentified hearing loss.

Still have a question?

Get free advice from our panel of experts

The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical exmanication, diagnosis and formal advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.

* You must accept our condition

Forum Rules