18 October 2010

Church criticised for Aids remarks

Belgium's Roman Catholic Church, already reeling from allegations of sexual abuse, faced a new scandal after its primate wrote that Aids was "a sort of inherent justice".


Belgium's Roman Catholic Church, already reeling from allegations of sexual abuse, faced a new scandal after its primate wrote that Aids was "a sort of inherent justice."

Many lawmakers condemned Archbishop Andre-Joseph Leonard, the head of the Belgian church, for the remarks in a new book. Belgium's Centre for Equal Opportunities received a series of complaints, including one by a lawyer who said his comments were incitement to hatred.

The Church is struggling to recover from the resignation of the Bishop of Bruges after he admitted sexually abusing a nephew.

Aids - a punishment from God

In his book "Monsignor Leonard - Conversations," the archbishop referred to a remark by the late Pope John Paul II who said, when asked whether Aids was a punishment from God, that it was difficult to judge God's will.

"I would not at all think in such terms. I do not see this illness as a punishment, at most a sort of inherent justice, a bit like how we are presented with the bill for what we do to the environment," Leonard said.

"Perhaps human love also wreaks revenge if it is mishandled without there having to be a transcendental source."

Jean Marie de Meester, a lawyer from Oostkamp near Bruges, said he had filed a complaint with the Centre for Equal Opportunities and Opposition to Racism.

Careful freedom of speech

"You can claim freedom of speech, but in his position he needs to be careful what he says. It has a lot of influence," he said.

"The comments are not just unfortunate. They are incitement to hatred. In its current condition, the Church does not have the moral right to judge others."

The Centre said it shared the indignation that the archbishop's comments had caused, even if they did not break the anti-discrimination law.

"He threatens to create a discriminatory climate for people with HIV or Aids and by extension people with other illnesses or a handicap," it said.

Misunderstood regarding Aids

Leonard told a news conference he felt he had been misunderstood as regarding Aids in all forms as a punishment. He said his words referred to promiscuous sex.

"It was not about Aids from a blood transfusion or as an illness with which someone has been born," he said. "If someone gets lung cancer from smoking, the cancer is a sort of inherent justice. The actions, consciously done, have a result."

He also said he was targeting "certain practices" and not HIV positive people or those with Aids, who should not be discriminated against. (Reuters Health/ October 2010)

Read more: Visit our HIV/AIDS centre


Complete our Health of the Nation Survey and stand a chance to win a scooter!


Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Ask the Expert

HIV/Aids expert

Dr Sindisiwe van Zyl qualified at the University of Pretoria in 2005. She is a patients' rights activist and loves using social media to teach about HIV. She is in private practice in Johannesburg.

Still have a question?

Get free advice from our panel of experts

The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical exmanication, diagnosis and formal advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.

* You must accept our condition

Forum Rules