Breast cancer

25 March 2010

Breast cancer screens don't save lives

Scientists said they had found no evidence that screening women for breast cancer has any effect on death rates, adding to an already fierce international debate.

Nordic scientists said they had found no evidence that screening women for breast cancer has any effect on death rates, adding to an already fierce international debate about routine testing.

In a study published in the British Medical Journal, researchers from Denmark and Norway said reductions in breast cancer death rates in regions with screening were the same or actually smaller than in areas where no women were screened.

"Our results are similar to what has been observed in other countries with nationally organised programmes," said Karsten Jorgensen of the Nordic Cochrane Centre in Copenhagen, who led the research.

"It is time to question whether screening has delivered the promised effect on breast cancer mortality."

Value of mammograms questioned

A row blew up in the United States in last November after public health officials on the US Preventive Services Task Force questioned the value of screening mammograms for women under 40 and suggested raising the annual screening age to 50.

Cancer doctors and advocacy groups denounced the move, saying the changes would mean more women would die from breast cancer. Some lawmakers said they may be used to ration healthcare.

Breast cancer is the most common cancer in women worldwide, accounting for around 16% of all female cancers. It kills around 519,000 people globally each year.

Jorgensen said that although breast cancer screening programmes vary by country, Denmark was a good benchmark and his team's findings should inform the debate.

Screening programs

In Denmark, women are screened every two years from age 50, while in the United States mammograms are now recommended every one to two years for women aged 50 plus, and in Britain the policy is for women over 50 to be screened about every 3 years.

Critics of widespread screening programmes say they can be more harmful than helpful if the extra hospital time and costs they require, coupled with the stress and worry of false alarms, are not outweighed by the benefit of preventing more deaths.

Risk-benefit balance

In Britain, for example, experts say around 7,000 women get an unnecessary breast cancer diagnosis when screening picks up tumours that would never have caused them any problems.

Jorgensen said his study showed this risk-benefit balance was not being hit in Denmark, and he speculated the situation would be the same in other developed countries.

Evidence now suggests that for every 2,000 women who are screened over 10 years, only one stands to have her life saved by the mammogram programme, he said, whereas the risk of getting an unnecessary breast cancer diagnosis is 10 times that.

Create awareness

"We need to make women aware that the chance they will benefit from the programme is very small," he said a telephone interview.

Jorgensen and his team compared annual changes in breast cancer deaths in two Danish regions with screening programmes against non-screened regions across the rest of Denmark.

In women likely to benefit from screening (those aged 55 to 74 years) breast cancer mortality fell by 1% a year in screened areas and by 2% a year in non-screened areas, the researchers found.

In women too young to benefit from screening (aged 35 to 54 years), breast cancer mortality declined by 5% a year in screened areas and by 6% a year in non-screened areas during the same period. - (Kate Kelland/Reuters Health, March 2010)


Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Ask the Expert

Breast cancer expert

Dr Gudgeon qualified in Birmingham, England, in 1968. She has more than 40 years experience in oncology, and in 1994 she founded her practice, Cape Breast Care, where she treats benign and malignant breast cancers. Dr Boeddinghaus obtained her qualification at UCT Medical School in 1994 and her MRCP in London in 1998. She has worked extensively in the field of oncology and has a special interest in the hormonal management of breast cancer. She now works with Dr Gudgeon at Cape Breast Care. Read more.

Still have a question?

Get free advice from our panel of experts

The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical exmanication, diagnosis and formal advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.

* You must accept our condition

Forum Rules