Updated 31 July 2017

Hydrolised infant formulas don't prevent autoimmune disorders

Experts encourage breast milk for infants rather than formulas after investigations reported that formulas didn't decrease the chances of asthma, allergies or diabetes.

Many parents who worry that their baby is at risk of asthma, allergies or type 1 diabetes may turn to special cow's milk formulas touted to lower the risk.

No consistent evidence

But a new review of the data on these "hydrolysed" infant formulas finds no good evidence that they actually protect children from the autoimmune disorders. Hydrolysed proteins are created by breaking food down into amino acids

"We found no consistent evidence to support a protective role for partially or extensively hydrolysed formula," concluded a team led by Robert Boyle of Imperial College London in England.

"Our findings conflict with current international guidelines, in which hydrolysed formula is widely recommended for young formula-fed infants with a family history of allergic disease," the study authors added.

Read: How is asthma treated?

One expert in the United States said the finding casts doubt on the usefulness of these special formula products.

"Allergies and autoimmune diseases such as asthma and type 1 diabetes are on the rise and it would be nice if we did have a clear route to preventing them," said Dr Ron Marino, associate chair of paediatrics at Winthrop-University Hospital in Mineola, New York.

"Unfortunately, despite U.S. Food and Drug Administration support for hydrolysed formula, the data are not compelling," he said.

Preventing autoimmune disorders

According to the British researchers, many infant feeding guidelines worldwide including North America, Australasia and Europe recommend hydrolysed cow's milk formula instead of standard infant formula to prevent autoimmune disorders during the first months of life.

Watch: How special formulas don't protect against allergies

Dr Punita Ponda is assistant chief of allergy and immunology at Northwell Health in Great Neck, New York. She stressed that when it comes to infant feeding, breast milk is by far the healthiest option.

However, "current mainstream guidelines for infant formula do recommend that parents consider using hypoallergenic formula if a close family member like an older brother or sister has a food allergy", she said. That was based on prior studies supporting some kind of protective effect, Ponda said.

However, the U.K. team found no consistent evidence to support the recommendations, according to their review published in the BMJ.

In the study, Boyle's team looked at data from 37 studies that together included more than 19,000 participants and were conducted between 1946 and 2015.

Read: Second-hand smoke tied to asthma in kids

The investigators found that infants who received hydrolysed cow's milk formula did not have a lower risk of asthma, allergies (such as eczema, hay fever, food allergies) or type 1 diabetes compared to those who received human breast milk or a standard cow's milk formula.

Conflict-of-interest and bias

The researchers also found no evidence to support an FDA-approved claim that a partially hydrolysed formula could reduce the risk of the skin disorder eczema, or another conclusion that hydrolysed formula could prevent an allergy to cow's milk.

Both Marino and Ponda believe that, based on the new report, it may be time to revisit guidelines that recommend hydrolysed formula.

"It is interesting that this [review] also finds conflict-of-interest and bias in many of the published studies" that supported the effectiveness of hydrolysed formulas, Marino said.

His opinion? "Most kids will have their best shot at a healthy life being raised on human breast milk," Marino said.

Ponda agreed that "the current recommendations might need to be revised". And she added, "even if there is no harm in using these formulas, they are often more costly and harder to find in the grocery stores".

Read more:

Are asthma symptoms stressing your teen out?

Poverty may affect the outcome of asthma treatment

Many women stop their asthma medications while pregnant

Image: Baby formula from iStock


Ask the Expert

Asthma Expert

Professor Keertan Dheda has received of several prestigious awards including the 2014 Oppenheimer Award, and has published over 160 peer-reviewed papers and holds 3 patents related to new TB diagnostic or infection control technologies. He serves on the editorial board of the journals PLoS One, the International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Medicine, Lancet Respiratory Diseases and Nature Scientific Reports, amongst others.Read his full biography at the University of Cape Town Lung Institute

Still have a question?

Get free advice from our panel of experts

The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical exmanication, diagnosis and formal advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.

* You must accept our condition

Forum Rules