11 June 2015

Wales to ban e-cigarettes in enclosed public places

The Welsh Health Minister said there was a danger that e-cigarettes could be a 'gateway' product which would encourage young people to take up regular cigarettes.


The Welsh government said on Tuesday it would bring in a law to stop the use of electronic cigarettes in workplaces and indoor public spaces, becoming the first part of the United kingdom to bring in such a ban amid concern about their use and safety.

Smoking should not seem acceptable

Mark Drakeford, the Health Minister for Wales, said there was a danger that e-cigarettes provided normalised smoking and would be a "gateway" product which would encourage young people to take up regular cigarettes.

Read: E-cigarette: is it worth trying?

"We certainly don't want to make smoking seem acceptable. It kills one in two of the people who are unfortunate enough to be taking up the habit," Drakeford told BBC radio.

"We don't want to look back in five or 10 years time and say how much we wish we had acted."

Wales outlawed smoking in enclosed public places in 2008, a year after a similar ban in England, but no date has yet been given for when the e-cigarette restriction would come in.

While many experts believe e-cigarettes, metal tubes which heat nicotine-laced liquid into an inhalable vapour, are a lower-risk alternative to smoking, other health officials say their impact needs greater study.

Potential unintended consequences

Drakeford said 40 other countries around the world had already brought the use of e-cigarettes into line with limits on the use of conventional ones, a move he said the World Health Organisation and British health officials had suggested was the best approach.

However, George Butterworth, tobacco policy manager at Cancer Research UK, said there was no evidence to justify a ban by arguing e-cigarettes normalised smoking or produced a vapour which was dangerous to others.

Read: We try the e-cigarette

"There are potential unintended consequences particularly that e-cigarettes are an opportunity for people to move away from tobacco smoking which is very, very bad for their health and we wouldn't want to put up any unnecessary barriers to prevent people from quitting cigarettes," he told BBC radio.

Drakeford said the Welsh ban was a balance and would do nothing to stop smokers using e-cigarettes to quit their habit.

The charity Action on Smoking and Health says more than 2 million adults in Britain use e-cigarettes and a survey in March said one in five teenagers had experimented with them. .

Two studies published in April found e-cigarettes could help some smokers quit, but that it depended on the type and how often they were used.

Read more:

Are e-cigarettes a gateway to smoking?

Superior e-cigarette designed in US

E-cigarettes may not be gateway to smoking

Image: Guy smoking e-cigarette from Shutterstock


Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

Gut health »

Can't lose weight? Blame it on your gut

Our nutrition experts weigh in on why gut health is such an important factor in weight loss, on World Obesity Day.

Sleep better »

Yes, there is such a thing as too much sleep

A new study confirms that too little sleep can impair your brain, but interestingly, too much sleep is also a problem.