Primary care doctors should screen all adults for drinking problems, and
offer them counselling if needed, new guidelines from the US Preventive Services
Task Force suggest.
Based on years of research, there is enough evidence that a quick screen at
the doctor's office can spot "risky" drinking, according to the task force, an
independent panel of medical experts that makes recommendations on screening and
other preventive health services.
The new guidelines are the panel's "final" recommendations on screening for
problem drinking. The last recommendations came out in 2004.
Since then, more research has been conducted, explained task force member Dr
Michael LeFevre, a professor of family and community medicine at the University
of Missouri School of Medicine in Columbia.
Catching risky drinking
In particular, LeFevre said, there's evidence that doctors can catch risky
drinking by asking just one question: How many times in the past year have you
had five or more drinks in a day (if you're a man), or four or more drinks (if
you're a woman or older than 65)?
If a patient acknowledges drinking that much, the doctor can ask more
questions to see how deep the problem goes.
An alcohol abuse expert not involved in the recommendations said the advice
to screen all adults is "right on."
"It's very well-supported by the literature," said Dr Marc Schuckit, a
professor of psychiatry at the University of California, San Diego, and editor
of the Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs.
The updated recommendations also clarify what doctors should be looking for:
the full range of what the task force calls alcohol "misuse."
That ranges from "risky" drinking, where people down more alcohol than they
should, to the more severe problems of alcohol abuse and alcohol dependence.
Dependence involves a physical addiction to alcohol, while alcohol abuse means
that drinking causes problems in people's personal and work lives.
LeFevre said there's good evidence that brief counselling from a primary care
doctor - even a single session of five to 15 minutes - can be enough to get
people to cut down on their drinking.
"Brief interventions are effective for people who are at the risky-drinking
stage," LeFevre said. However, people with more serious drinking problems will
likely need more help, or referral to a specialist program, he added.
Techniques to curb drinking
Alcohol misuse is a common problem, Schuckit said. An estimated 21% of US
adults admit to risky drinking, while about 4% are thought to have full-blown
alcohol dependence, according to the task force. Problem drinking is also blamed
for more than 85 000 deaths each year in the United States, which makes it the
third-leading cause of preventable deaths behind smoking and obesity.
"In my opinion, all clinicians should be screening for alcohol problems and
offering brief interventions," Schuckit said.
He and LeFevre said any primary care doctor can learn brief counselling
techniques. These might include helping patients find healthy ways to reduce
stress or set goals for curbing their drinking.
When it comes to teenagers, though, the task force said there is not enough
evidence to recommend routine screening.
"We don't know enough," LeFevre said. "We can't assume that what we've found
to work for adults also works for kids." There's no agreement, for example, on
whether there's a "safe" level of drinking for a teenager, he said. So would
doctors have to intervene with all teens who admitted to any amount of
"We are not saying that adolescent drinking is an issue doctors should
ignore. It is a problem," LeFevre said. "This is really a call to the research
community that we need more evidence [on screening teenagers]."
The American Academy of Pediatrics disagrees, however. It recommends that
doctors ask all adolescent patients about their drinking habits.
Learn more about problem
drinking from the US National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and