Exercise is good for your heart, and monitoring your heart rate during exercise can be a great help if you know which heart rate zone you should aim for.
Fitbits and other wrist-worn fitness devices promise to keep track of your heart rate, but new research suggests they are less accurate than thought during certain exercises.
"If you need to know your heart rate with accuracy when exercising – either because you are training for a marathon or have safe heart rate limits set by your doctor, perhaps due to coronary artery disease, heart failure or other heart conditions – wrist-worn monitors are less accurate than the standard chest strap," study author Dr Marc Gillinov said in an American College of Cardiology news release.
The study is to be presented at the upcoming annual meeting of the
American College of Cardiology, in Washington, D.C. Findings presented
at meetings are typically viewed as preliminary until they've been
published in a peer-reviewed journal.
Wrist devices were up to 34 beats off
heart rates on the wrist-worn devices were compared to those from a
continuous 4-lead electrocardiogram (EKG) and a chest strap monitor.
Like an EKG, the chest strap measures electrical activity of the heart.
on the type of activity, the wrist devices were up to 34 beats a minute
off. The wrist trackers could either overestimate or underestimate
heart rate, Gillinov said. He's a heart valve research, thoracic and
cardiovascular surgery expert at the Cleveland Clinic.
included 50 volunteers. Their average age was 38. They tested popular
wrist-worn fitness trackers, including the Apple Watch, Fitbit Blaze,
Garmin Forerunner 235, and TomTom Spark Cardio.
heart rates were recorded at rest and after light, moderate and vigorous
exercise on a treadmill, stationary bike and elliptical trainer. All of
them exercised for 18 minutes.
The chest strap monitor closely matched the readings from the EKG, which is the gold standard for measuring heart rate.
And the wrist-worn devices were fairly accurate when a person was at rest.
We want to know what you think
Accuracy varies with type of exercise
Most wrist devices gave acceptable readings during treadmill activity, but were fairly inaccurate while bicycling or using the elliptical, the study revealed.
Fitbit's maker took issue with the findings.
"We stand behind our heart-tracking technology. Fitbit trackers are not intended to be medical devices," Fitbit said in a statement. "Unlike chest straps, wrist-based trackers fit conveniently and comfortably into everyday life, providing continuous heart rate for up to several days without recharging [the device's batteries]."
The San Francisco-based company added that internal studies involving 60 volunteers showed the device has an average error of 6% or less for measuring a person's heart beat. And the Fitbit was tested against devices like the chest strap during walking, running, biking, using the elliptical and more, the company added.
Of all the wrist devices tested, the Apple watch seemed to fare the best. It performed well during bicycling and on elliptical machines without arm levels. The Apple watch's heart rate monitor was only noticeably inaccurate compared to the chest strap when used on an elliptical machine with arm levers, the researchers said.
Why might there be inaccuracies?
Wrist-worn devices use optical sensing, or light, to measure blood flow, the researchers said.
"It's not measuring what the heart does, but rather blood flow – basically the volume of blood in the tissue," Gillinov explained.
Wrist-worn devices also introduce many more variables that can result in incorrect readings, including insufficient contact with the skin due to sweating, poor fit or skin colour, he said.
"Even though all these wrist-worn monitors work by the same general principles, there is considerable variation among them," he said.
"Overall, they were most accurate when someone was using the treadmill at low intensity and worst when exercising on the elliptical at high intensity," Gillinov added.
WATCH: Keeping fit doesn't need to cost a cent
4 ways to fit exercise into your life
How men can get younger looking skin