Publications
Partners
The researchers, from the Erasmus Medical Center in Rotterdam, recruited 5 289 people over the age of 55 and found that those with the highest total vitamin B6 intake had significantly lower risk of developing the disease than those with the lowest intake.
Parkinson’s disease, named after Dr James Parkinson, the London doctor who initially identified it as a particular condition, occurs when nerve cells are lost in a part of the brain called the substantia nigra.
How the study was done
The Rotterdam Study looked into reports that increased levels of the amino acid homocysteine might promote Parkinson’s disease. Numerous studies have reported that higher intakes of folate, vitamin B12, and vitamin B6 decrease plasma homocysteine levels and therefore might offer protection from Parkinson’s.
It has also been proposed that vitamin B6 could have antioxidant effects that could reduce the risk of the disease by a mechanism that is not related to homocysteine.
The researchers, led by Dr Monique Breteler, assessed dietary intakes at the very start of the study (October 1990 to July 2003) using semi-quantitative food frequency questionnaires (SFFQ). Physical examinations of the subjects, including neurological examinations, were conducted at baseline and at three yearly intervals.
After an average of ten years of follow-up, 72 new cases of Parkinson’s disease had been diagnosed.
The average vitamin B6 intake was 1,63mg per day, average B12 intake was 5,3mcg per day, and average folate intake of 218,7mcg per day.
Good results seen with B6
The researchers found that people who had daily vitamin B6 intakes of 230,9mcg or more had an associated risk of developing Parkinson’s disease 54 percent lower than people who had average daily intakes lower than 185,1mcg.
No significant reductions in the risk of Parkinson’s disease were found for folate or vitamin B12, although the authors could “not completely rule out” an effect from these nutrients.
When the researchers limited their calculations to smokers, who made up 66 percent of the study population, they found that the protective effects of high vitamin B6 intake appeared to be limited to this group.
“Stratified analyses showed that this association was restricted to smokers,” wrote the authors.
“It is unclear why higher vitamin B6 intake was associated with a decreased risk of Parkinson’s disease only in smokers,” said the authors.
But Breteler and her team noted that several studies have reported that nicotine may protect brain cells and reduce the risk of Parkinson’s disease, and suggest that vitamin B6 plus smoking may “mutually reinforce beneficial effects”.
Alternative mechanism?
Homocysteine is potentially toxic to brain cells, but since no relationship between folate and vitamin B12 was observed, the authors said that the apparent benefits of B6 “may point towards an alternative mechanism… [because] several lines of evidence suggest neuroprotective properties of vitamin B6 through antioxidant capacities”.
“Because oxidative stress may be prominent in Parkinson’s disease pathogenesis, higher vitamin B6 intake may thus reduce Parkinson’s disease risk though antioxidant effects.”
The results, which do not agree with the one previous study looking at B-vitamin intake and Parkinson’s disease, need to be confirmed in both additional observational studies and clinical trials, said the researchers.
The previous study, based in the US, followed a population sample with significantly higher daily intakes of all three B vitamins, which may account for the discrepancy between that study and the Rotterdam Study, said the researchers.
The results are published in the journal Neurology (Vol. 67, pp. 315-318). - (Decision News Media, August 2006)
Read more:
