Implanting single embryos into the wombs of women seeking to boost fertility is more effective and less costly than placing two embryos at a time, a pair of studies found.
The research contradicts the widely-held view that implanting multiple embryos during in-vitro fertilisation (IVF) is more cost-effective, and improves a woman's chances of becoming pregnant.
"At a time when there is an intense debate in many countries about how to reduce multiple pregnancy rates and provide affordable fertility treatment, policy makers should be made aware of our results," said the study's lead researcher Hannu Martikainen of the
University of Oulu in Finland.
"These data should also encourage clinics to evaluate their embryo transfer policy and adopt elective single embryo transfer as their everyday practice for women younger than 40," she said.
The issue grabbed headlines earlier this year when a 33-year-old woman in California who underwent IVF gave birth to octuplets. All of the infants survived, but multiple pregnancies are notoriously linked to premature births, low birthweight and neurological damage.
Some medical associations and governments have moved to tighten guidelines or regulations restricting the number of embryos that can be implanted during in-vitro fertilisation (IVF).
In Britain the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) controls IVF practices, limiting implanted embryos to two at a time. Just a single embryo will be allowed from 2011.
There are no national regulations in the United States. Professional guidelines suggest that a woman under 35 should have no more than two implanted embryos. This can be increased to three from 35 to 37 years, to four embryos for ages 37-40, and five for a woman aged over 40.
How the study was done
In the new study, Martikainen and colleagues compared the outcomes of more than 3 600 assisted reproduction cycles at a major Finnish clinic across two time periods, 1995 to 1999, and 2000 to 2004. More than 1 500 women under 40 were treated.
During the first period, double embryo transfer was the norm, with single embryos being implanted in only 4% of women. During the second period, that percentage went up to 46.
The study found that the live birth rate was five percent higher for women who had only one embryo implanted at a time. The single embryo procedure was also cheaper, especially when health complications due to multiple births were taken into account.
"We found that a baby born alive at term using single embryo transfer was, on average, 19 899 euros less
expensive than babies born as a result of double embryo transfer," Martikainen said. – (Sapa, March 2009)
New fertility treatment promising
Octuplets shock fertility experts