Updated 12 November 2014

US: Smack children but not with implements

The majority of US citizens believe that smacking a child at home is perfectly fine, but it should not involve implements.


Nearly seven in 10 Americans believe spanking a child is acceptable at home and a majority say corporal punishment is tolerable provided it does not involve implements such as the one a National Football League star used on his son, a Reuters/Ipsos poll found.

The findings help explain where Americans stand on corporal punishment after the indictment on child abuse charges of Adrian Peterson, a top NFL running back, in a case that sparked a contentious public debate over what is acceptable.

The 29-year-old Minnesota Viking allegedly left bruises and wounds on his 4-year-old son while disciplining him with the whippy end of a tree branch, called a switch, an act that Peterson has publicly admitted to.

The online survey of 3,637 adults found that about 68 percent approved of spanking at home, and that figure varied little between race and income groups.

Read: The corporal punishment debate continues

Corporal punishment more popular in Southwest

But there were regional differences. About eight in 10 respondents from the Southwest, which included Peterson's home state of Texas, said corporal punishment should be allowed at home, while just over half of New England respondents held that view.

A majority of respondents, about 60 percent, said corporal punishment was acceptable if it doesn't leave a physical mark, about the same number who said it should be allowed if it doesn't involve an implement such as a belt, cane or paddle.

"I don't care what age the child is or what they did, you don't use anything but your hand. I'm sorry, but that just goes above and beyond as far as I am concerned," said respondent Esther Negrin, 78, of Las Vegas, Nevada.

Negrin said a "swat on the behind" was a very rare occurrence while she was raising her three children.

Read: 80% of kids still spanked

Majority punished as children

The survey supports the belief that corporal punishment is employed less these days in the United States than decades ago.

Three in four respondents said they had received corporal punishment as a child, more whites than minorities, and whites with children at home were slightly more likely to say they had carried out corporal punishment than were minorities.

More older respondents reported receiving corporal punishment than did younger adults.

After his 12th of September indictment, Peterson, a 2012 NFL most valuable player, said he disciplined his son the way he was as a child and caused an injury he never intended or thought would happen.

Poll respondent Joyce Ray, 72, said she used the technique of "time out" a lot while raising 10 children.

"I don't believe in people beating on their children or starving them or things like that as punishment," said Ray, a retired seamstress from Junction City, Oregon.

"But I do believe that a swat across the fanny is not going to hurt them any and maybe will teach them a lesson," she added.

Read: Spare the rod and develop the child

NFL domestic violence

The Peterson case is one of five recent domestic violence incidents involving NFL players that have raised questions about the league's handling of disciplinary cases. It is the only one involving a child.

About 12 percent of respondents strongly disagreed with corporal punishment being allowed at home.

Poll respondent Donald Barton, like the American Academy of Paediatrics, said he strongly opposes corporal punishment including spanking for children in part because it sends the message that physical force is acceptable.

"Timeouts are good because they make the kids concentrate on what they did, rather than pain," said Barton, 61, who lives in Detroit, Michigan.

The paediatrics academy has said physical discipline of children has been linked to a range of mental health problems and can make children more aggressive.

The poll was conducted from the 19th to the 30th of September as the NFL struggled with questions over initial light punishment for Peterson and former Baltimore Ravens running back Ray Rice.

Peterson was reactivated to play after he sat out one game following the indictment, but on the 17th of September the Vikings reversed course and suspended him indefinitely as criticism mounted from fans and sponsors. He is scheduled to appear in court on the 8th of October.

Read more:

Child abuse increases suicide risk
Domestic violence slows kids' development
European spanking ban called for

Image: Boy standing up against wall from Shutterstock


Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

Exercise benefits for seniors »

Working out in the concrete jungle Even a little exercise may help prevent dementia Here’s an unexpected way to boost your memory: running

Seniors who exercise recover more quickly from injury or illness

When sedentary older adults got into an exercise routine, it curbed their risk of suffering a disabling injury or illness and helped them recover if anything did happen to them.