26 February 2013

Paediatricians oppose school suspension, expulsion

A group representing paediatricians says disciplining students with out-of-school suspension or expulsion is counterproductive to school goals and should only be used on case by case basis.


A group representing paediatricians says disciplining students with out-of-school suspension or expulsion is counter-productive to school goals and should only be used on case by case basis.

The policy statement from the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends that paediatricians familiarise themselves with the policies of their local school districts, and advocate for prevention and alternative strategies.

"The adverse effect of out-of-school suspension and expulsion on the student can be profound," the experts wrote.

"Data suggest that students who are involved in the juvenile justice system are likely to have been suspended or expelled. Further, students who experience out-of-school suspension and expulsion are as much as 10 times more likely to ultimately drop out of high school than are those who do not," they add.

Kathy Cowan, director of communications for the National Association of School Psychologists in Bethesda, Maryland, said their organisation largely supports the AAP's statements. "Sometimes (out-of-school suspension and expulsion) are absolutely necessary, but they're not effective at improving behaviour in general," Cowan said.

The AAP says students who are punished with out-of-school suspension and expulsion may be left without supervision during the day and engage in more inappropriate behaviour.

The experts also say out-of-school suspension and expulsion does not deal with possible underlying issues, such as drug abuse, racial tension, violence and bullying.

Early interventions

In addition to the costs incurred by the school district from disciplinary hearings and providing services for the child, the paediatricians say there is also a cost to society.

"A high-school dropout will earn less over a lifetime than a high school graduate. The dropout will pay less in taxes," they write.

To prevent out-of-school suspensions and expulsions, the paediatricians suggest developing early interventions for preschool children, early identification of children who may have problems in school and clear codes of conduct.

Specifically, they recommend a Positive Behavior Intervention and Support program as a preventive, alternative, tool that teaches proper behaviour on a school-wide level and that addresses problems with groups and individual students as well.

The AAP also called on Paediatricians to screen for and recognise behavioural problems in early childhood, to be in communication with the school's nurse or counsellor, to be involved with special accommodations for certain students and to be appropriately compensated for their involvement. Cowan said the AAP should be applauded for their efforts.

"Paediatricians are such an important voice on these issues, because parents trust the paediatricians and they're the ones seeing kids," she said. Dr Jeffrey Lamont, the policy statement's lead author, did not respond to requests for comment.




Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

Are you sure? »

Aid your digestion What are digestive disorders?

Are you really constipated?

Many people think that if they do not have two or more bowel movements every single day of their lives they are constipated. This is patently not true, writes DietDoc.

True of False? »

SEE: How anaphylactic shock affects your body

Stop believing these 10 allergy myths

Do you still believe that hay fever is caused by hay? Or that food allergies are really common? No, and no again. We bust 10 myths about allergies.