26 September 2014

Damages for adultery no longer allowed

The Supreme Court of Appeal has ruled that adultery is no longer a legal basis for claiming compensation for harm.


Adultery is no longer a legal basis for claiming compensation for harm, according to a Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) ruling this week.

"In the light of the changing mores of our society, the delictual action based on adultery of the innocent spouse has become outdated and can no longer be sustained," Judge FDJ Brand said in the judgment issued by the court.

"The time for its abolition has come."

The SCA ruling followed an appeal by a Gauteng man ordered by the High Court in Johannesburg to pay R75,000 in damages to another man whose wife he had an affair with.

Protecting marriage

The SCA, on accepting the appeal hearing, asked that lawyers for the parties address the issue of whether adultery should remain part of the law when seen against the morals of society, the Constitution, and marriage as an institution.

Read: 10 dangers to your marriage

The SCA upheld the appeal against the damages ordered.

Brand said the intention in his ruling was not to suggest a judgment on the "possible moral blameworthiness" of conduct like adultery. Rather it was to ensure that defendants were not legally liable for their actions.

He acknowledged that while the law related to adultery was often intended to protect marriage, he questioned whether it was a successful means to achieve this aim.

"Marriage is one of the most important institutions in our society which is and should be recognised and protected by our Constitution."

Brand, however, pointed out that allowing damages for adultery would not necessarily help protect marriage.

Adultery the result

"It is now widely recognised that causes for the breakdown in marriages are far more complex. Quite frequently adultery is found to be the result, and not the cause, of an unhappy marital relationship."

He said the concept of protecting the wounded feelings of the wronged party ran counter to the nature of law to work only with what was objectively reasonable.

Read: How to affair-proof your marriage

"If the law is to be extended to protect wounded feelings, where would we draw the line? Would it include the wounded feelings of a party whose agreement to marry had been broken, or of a man whose girlfriend had left him for another?"

Brand suggested it was an anomaly that the damages claim was only available against the third party, and not the adulterous spouse.

"If anything, the behaviour of the guilty spouse is patently more reprehensible... and more hurtful to the innocent spouse.... it is after all the guilty spouse, not the third party, who solemnly undertook to remain faithful and who is bound by a relationship of trust."

Referring to the case that prompted this fresh look at the adultery law, Brand suggested its proceedings ultimately caused more damage than promoted remedy.

Emotional trauma

He suggested that the young children involved in the now broken-up marriage had been exposed to "harmful publicity and emotional trauma".

Read: Divorce takes toll on kids

The adulterous spouse's dignity and right to privacy had been harmed through "embarrassing and demeaning cross-examination".

Brand said the impression created was that the plaintiff had been motivated by a desire for revenge, rather than solace or comfort.

"He found the defendant a convenient scapegoat and repository of his anger... I have no doubt that this is often the case."

Read more:

Divorce takes toll on kids
Men programmed to steer clear of friends' wives
The sexless affair

Image: Judge's gavel from shutterstock

See breaking news and the hottest health tips before anybody else by joining South Africa’s biggest and best health community, like health24 on Facebook now!





Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

Exercise benefits for seniors »

Working out in the concrete jungle Even a little exercise may help prevent dementia Here’s an unexpected way to boost your memory: running

Seniors who exercise recover more quickly from injury or illness

When sedentary older adults got into an exercise routine, it curbed their risk of suffering a disabling injury or illness and helped them recover if anything did happen to them.