27 July 2011

Wait before treating victims

Flashbacks, fear, guilt and anger will torment survivors of the shooting attacks in Norway, but health experts say doctors should wait before flooding them with trauma counselling.


Flashbacks, fear, guilt and anger will torment the minds of survivors of the shooting and bomb attacks in Norway, but mental health experts say doctors should resist the temptation to rush in and flood them with trauma counselling.

More effective is to watch and wait a few weeks, allowing those who saw loved ones die, or played dead to avoid being killed themselves, to go through a natural process of recovery. Norway and its people will recover, experts say, and they'll do so quite swiftly if a careful and targeted treatment strategy is deployed.

Dr Neil McGibbon, our Teen Expert is a Clinical Psychologist, who worked with trauma survivors in Northern Ireland and at the Traumatic Stress Service in South West London says that in a case such as this there is a very real danger of de-skilling and 'pathologising people' if professionals rush in with trauma debriefing. 

"We have levels of resilience that are sometimes put to the test by traumatic events, and it is crucial that time is given to allow for an individual’s natural self-healing capacities. This is not about leaving someone to suffer, it is about monitoring the situation and a person’s symptoms over time. 

"Normalising their responses in the early stages can help strengthen someone’s recovery rather than them being disempowered by others intervening. Only if the symptoms persist and someone’s mental state is deteriorating, is it necessary for professional intervention.  Watch and wait is indeed an approach I support, " he says. (Visit Dr McGibbon's Teen Forum here).

Monica Thompson, a clinical psychologist who co-coordinated the trauma response to the 2007 London suicide bombings, said much has been learned from previous mass killings like the September 11, 2001 attacks in the United States.

Pushing survivors into counselling 'not helpful'

"It's quite understandable and natural for people to be traumatised, shocked and take a while to adjust, but on the whole the majority of people come out of it relatively unscathed," Thompson, from London's Camden and Islington NHS Foundation Trust, said in a telephone interview.

Lawyers, psychiatrists and police were discussing the mental health of Anders Behring Breivik after the anti-Islam radical admitted to a bombing and shooting spree that killed 76 people. More than 100,000 Norwegians attended a rally in Oslo, many carrying white and red roses in mourning.

Thompson said that while it was important for survivors and grieving relatives to feel that there are people there who can appreciate what they're going though, it's also crucial not to push them into formal counselling unless, and until, they need it.

"What they tried to do after 9/11 was to give everybody counselling and therapy, literally en masse. And that actually isn't helpful, because those responses of fear, shock, thinking about it all the time, having nightmares about it are all perfectly normal. It's a natural process."

Common symptoms after the shooting

Re-experiencing symptoms, or flashbacks, such as sudden images or sounds of blood being spattered or the gunman opening fire, or the look of fear in a victim's eyes, will be common in the first weeks but should gradually fade away.

Roughly 20 to 30% of those most closely involved in such experiences will still have symptoms a month or so later and may develop mental health problems, such as post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and need specialist help.

Jennifer Wild, a clinical psychologist at the Institute of Psychiatry at King's College London, said the toughest psychological issues for the survivors of the shooting spree and those closest to the bombing would be guilt, loss and fear.

"One of the most difficult emotions to deal with is survivors' guilt," she said. "And because it was so unexpected, there will also be feelings of fear that the world is unpredictable, that anything could happen at any time. When those beliefs start to develop and become rooted in somebody, it can really affect their behaviour."

Counselling in the aftermath

For those who continue to have flashbacks, and who are still finding it difficult to sleep or seek to block memories from their minds, experts say counselling known as trauma-focused therapy can be very effective.

This involves cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) aimed at helping people to process the traumatic memories by talking about the experience, reliving it in their minds, understanding their own responses and shifting the experience into their long-term memory, where it will gradually stop flashing back.

Wild, who has worked in Norway, advised health authorities there to adopt a screen and treat strategy, similar to one deployed after the London 2007 attacks in which suicide bombers killed 52 people.

"That programme was very effective," she said, with sufferers of PTSD likely to be helped to recover within a matter of months of counselling sessions once a week.

"One of the things we've learnt from major incidents and terrible tragedies like this is that, thankfully, human beings are incredibly resilient," she said. "A nation can recover."

(Reuters Health, July 2011)

Read more:




Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

Exercise benefits for seniors »

Working out in the concrete jungle Even a little exercise may help prevent dementia Here’s an unexpected way to boost your memory: running

Seniors who exercise recover more quickly from injury or illness

When sedentary older adults got into an exercise routine, it curbed their risk of suffering a disabling injury or illness and helped them recover if anything did happen to them.