The key to correctly diagnosing when a case of dizziness is just vertigo or a
life-threatening stroke may be surprisingly simple: a pair of goggles that
measures eye movement at the bedside in as little as one minute, a new study
"This is the first study demonstrating that we can accurately discriminate
strokes and non-strokes using this device," said Dr David Newman-Toker, lead
author of a paper on the technique that is published in the April issue of the
Some 100 000 strokes are misdiagnosed as something else each year in the
United States, resulting in 20 000 to 30 000 deaths or severe physical and
speech impairments, the researchers said.
Speed is important
As with heart attacks, the key to treating stroke and potentially saving a
person's life is speed. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), the current gold
standard for assessing stroke, can take up to six hours to complete and costs $1
200, said Newman-Toker, who is an associate professor of neurology and
otolaryngology at Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore.
Sometimes people don't even get as far as an MRI, and may be sent home with a
first "mini stroke" that is followed by a devastating second stroke, he
The new study findings come with some significant caveats, however.
For one thing, the study was a small one, involving only 12 patients.
"It is impossible for a small study to prove 100% accuracy," said Dr Daniel
Labovitz, director of the Stern Stroke Center at Montefiore Medical Center in
New York City, who was not involved with the study. About 4% of dizziness cases
in the emergency room are caused by stroke.
The other caveat is that the device is not yet approved in the United States
for diagnosing stroke. The US Food and Drug Administration only recently gave it
approval for use in assessing balance. It has been available in Europe for that
purpose for about a year.
The device - known as a video-oculography machine - is a modification of a
"head impulse test," which is used regularly for people with chronic dizziness
and other inner ear-balance disorders.
"There are 500 otolaryngologists and 4 million dizzy patients in the US
alone," Newman-Toker said. "We [otolaryngologists] can't see everybody and
[emergency room physicians] can't easily be trained to develop expertise in eye
"Now we have a device that can do it for them," he added.
How the test is done
The test is simple to perform: Wearing a pair of goggles hooked up to a
webcam and special software, the patient is asked to focus on one spot on the
wall while the doctor moves the patient's head from side to side.
"Normally, the balance system in the ears keeps our eyes stable when our head
is moving," Newman-Toker explained.
For people with vertigo, the test is "almost always abnormal," he said. But
stroke patients, even though they have the same dizzy symptoms, don't have this
In this small, "proof-of-concept" study, the test was 100% accurate when
compared with MRI, sorting out six people with strokes and six without, the
Newman-Toker believes the test could one day be incorporated into a smart
Labovitz said the device could be a "game changer" if its value is confirmed
in larger studies. "This is such an important area where we struggle all the
time," he said.
GN Otometrics, which makes the device, loaned the devices for the study, but
the research was funded by the US National Institutes of Health and other Swiss
and US health organisations.
The US National
Library of Medicine has more on stroke.