Genetics

01 September 2010

Stem cell funding block appealed

The Obama administration appealed a ruling that blocked federal funding of human embryonic stem cell research, asking the judge who issued the injunction to put it on hold.

0

The Obama administration has appealed a ruling that blocked federal funding of human embryonic stem cell research, asking the judge who issued the injunction to put it on hold pending the appeal.

The Justice Department asked Judge Royce Lamberth to lift the injunction he imposed after two doctors sued over the administration's policy, saying it violated US law because it involved destroying embryos and that it also made it more difficult for them to win federal research grants.

Lamberth's injunction was harming current federally funded human embryonic stem cell research and could force a halt to all research that is subject to government funding, the Justice Department said.

Jeopardising the benefit

"Numerous ongoing projects will likely not survive even a temporary gap in funds, jeopardising both the potential benefit of the research and the hundreds of millions of dollars of taxpayer funds already invested in it," the filing said.

The two researchers had argued that the new policy broadening National Institutes of Health funding for human embryonic stem cell research made it harder for them to win grants for their adult stem cell research, an argument the Justice Department disputed.

The two doctor's "remote economic self-interests do not outweigh the harm the injunction will cause NIH, the hundreds of affected human embryonic stem cell researchers, and the millions of individuals who hold out hope that human embryonic stem cell research will lead to the cure for, or treatment of, their currently incurable illnesses," the Justice Department said.

Renewed federal funding

The administration pointed to 24 projects up for renewed federal funding between now and the end of September and said the benefits from the research could be lost.

The Justice Department asked Lamberth to rule by 7 September 2010 on the request to lift his injunction during the appeal.

President Barack Obama opened the door to broader federal funding of human embryonic stem cell research as one of his first acts after taking office in 2009, overturning his predecessor George W. Bush's limitations on the work.

Guidelines for the research

The NIH issued guidelines for the research, which Dr James Sherley, a biological engineer at Boston Biomedical Research Institute, and Theresa Deisher, of Washington-based AVM Biotechnology, then challenged.

Supporters of human embryonic stem cell research say it is vital to carry it out alongside other types of stem cell research to understand how to transform cells into desired tissue types and treat diseases ranging from juvenile diabetes to blindness.

Opponents say it is wrong to destroy human embryos, even days-old embryos to be discarded from fertility clinics. (Reuters Health/ August 2010)

Read more: Stem Cell ruling upsets scientists

 

Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
0 comments
Comments have been closed for this article.