14 March 2011

Study challenges carb counting in diabetes

Carbohydrate content might be less important for blood sugar control than glycaemia load, according to a new study of healthy adults.


Carbohydrate content might be less important for blood sugar control than glycaemia load, according to a new study of healthy adults.

The study questions the way patients with type 1 diabetes determine how much insulin they should take before meals.

Jiansong Bao at the University of Sydney in Australia and colleagues took finger-prick blood samples from 10 healthy young people who ate a total of 120 different types of food - all with the same kilojoule content.

The glycaemia load repeatedly trumped the carb count in predicting the blood sugar and insulin rise after a meal.

Carbs and type 1 diabetes

"It suggests that the methods used to assess carbs in persons with type 1 diabetes might benefit from some rethinking," said Dr Edward J. Boyko, a diabetes expert at the University of Washington in Seattle who wasn't involved in the study.

But he said it wasn't certain the findings would hold up in people who aren't completely healthy.

"In the US, 60% of people are overweight or obese so we don't know how the results would apply to them or to persons with diabetes," he told.

The glycaemia load is calculated by multiplying the amount of carbs in grams per serving by the food's glycaemia index divided by 100. The glycaemia index for a variety of foods can be found at http://www.glycemicindex.com/.

Foods with a low glycaemia index cause the blood sugar to rise slowly.

The findings

Writing online in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, the researchers say their findings also suggest that eating foods with high glycaemia loads could be linked to chronic disease like type 2 diabetes and heart disease.

But that is not clear from the study, which only looked at blood sugar and insulin changes up to two hours after a meal, said Dr Boyko.

"It would just be speculation whether a dietary change like this would help people with type 2 diabetes," he told.

Long-term effects and other nutrients in the food might also be important for disease risk, for instance. And the most important problem remains pure and simple overeating, according to Dr Boyko.

"The excess weight is the main thing we ought to focus on," he said. "The simplest message would be, eat less."(Reuters Health/ March 2011)

Read more:
The lowdown on carbo-loading


Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Ask the Expert

Diabetes expert

Dr. May currently works as a fulltime endocrinologist and has been in private practice since 2004. He has a variety of interests, predominantly obesity and diabetes, but also sees patients with osteoporosis, thyroid disorders, men's health disorders, pituitary and adrenal disorders, polycystic ovaries, and disorders of growth. He is a leading member of several obesity and diabetes societies and runs a trial centre for new drugs.

Still have a question?

Get free advice from our panel of experts

The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical exmanication, diagnosis and formal advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.

* You must accept our condition

Forum Rules