Women with breast implants could run the risk of having breast cancer
diagnosed at later stages, when survival might be worse, according to Canadian
Breast implants can make it more difficult to diagnose breast cancer early
because they block some areas of the breast on mammograms, experts say.
"Women who currently have breast implants and those considering breast
augmentation should be aware of the possible long-term health effects of
cosmetic breast implants," said lead author Eric Lavigne, a PhD graduate in
epidemiology with the faculty of medicine at University Laval, in Quebec
"They should also be reassured that physicians and other health professionals
will continue to offer the best medical practices to these women," he added.
To see whether breast implants had an effect on breast cancer diagnosis and
survival, Lavigne's team reviewed studies published after 1993. This process,
known as a meta-analysis, attempts to find a consistent pattern from different
studies. In many cases, these patterns aren't the focus of or apparent from each
individual study, but emerge only after the data are combined.
In this case, by analysing 12 studies, the researchers found that women with
breast implants had a 26% increased risk of being diagnosed with late-stage
breast cancer compared to women without implants.
When Lavigne's group looked at another five studies, they found that women
with breast implants had a 38% increased risk of dying from breast cancer than
women without implants.
This finding "may be explained by the advanced breast cancer diagnosis
received," Lavigne said.
These results, however, need to be interpreted with caution since only a
small number of studies were included in this summary, and many factors in each
study can affect the overall results, he said.
Although the analysis linked breast implants to later-stage breast cancer
diagnoses, it did not establish a cause-and-effect relationship.
Dr Stephanie Bernik, chief of surgical oncology at Lenox Hill Hospital in New
York City, said she will be more cautious with patients.
"Patients ask if it's OK to do implants," Bernik said. "We don't tell them
not to, but they have to understand that it comes with a risk of obscuring some
of the breast tissue."
If someone has a family history of breast cancer, they should be cautious,
Bernik said. "Everybody should be informed that there is this problem," she
said. "It will limit the ability for cancer detection with mammography."
Bernik suggested that women with breast implants also have an ultrasound or
MRI to get around the problem of the implant hiding breast tissue during a
mammogram. She said, however, that for this purpose MRIs aren't covered by
To learn more about breast cancer, visit the American