Updated 12 February 2013

Are dogs the real culprits?

More people are allergic to cats than dogs. However, a new study shows dog allergens are more ferocious irritants to asthmatics than cat dander, cockroaches, mold and dust mites.


Rex may be your best pal, but if you've got asthma he is your lungs' worst enemy.

More people are allergic to cats than dogs. However, a 2003 study showed dog allergens are more ferocious irritants to asthmatics than cat dander, cockroaches, mold and dust mites.

The researchers presented their findings May 2003 at a meeting of the American Thoracic Society in Seattle.

The research study
The study included 809 men and women with mild to moderate asthma who underwent skin tests for various irritants.

To measure their sensitivity to an allergen, the researchers tested subjects in four areas: their ability to exhale while exposed to an irritant (weaker is worse); the amount of nitric oxide gas in their breath (more signals inflammation); and the nature of the phlegm, if any, they coughed up (cells called eosinophils present in mucus reflect inflammation). They also provoked their lungs with a drug that simulates constricted airways.

Cat allergens were most likely to trigger at least one of these reactions, doing so in nearly three-quarters of the volunteers, the most of any irritant. Dog dander, by comparison, did so only about half as frequently.

Dog dander decrease lung function
However, dog dander was the irritant most likely to decrease lung function, constrict the airways and provoke inflammation.

Research has suggested cats in the home can protect infants from early-childhood asthma. However, the 2003 study showed that both dogs and cats are a problem for adults with the breathing problem.

"Once you have asthma, both of the critters can increase inflammation and decrease the stability of asthma," said Dr Tim Craig, a paediatrician at US Pennsylvania State University College of Medicine and a collaborator on the work.

Pollen not as bad
Interestingly, the researchers say, pollens didn't seem to exacerbate the lungs as much as dog and cat dander and other indoor irritants. "Though they cause significant symptoms, like runny noses and itchy eyes, they may not be as important triggers of asthma as indoor allergens are," Craig says.

Dr Clifford Bassett, a New York City allergy specialist, says the new findings run counter to what most asthma experts have believed. "Normally we thought cat dander was most provocative," says Bassett, who sits on the public education committee of the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology.

Don't sell your dog yet
Some doctors say pets are a no-go for asthma patients. Bassett says it's possible to keep animals around, as long as you take steps to reduce your exposure to their allergens. Using special air filters to intercept the particles is one way, while lower-tech measures such as wearing cotton (wool's a magnet for pet dander) and keeping your animal out of the bedroom help, too. "Keeping your pet out of the bedroom can reduce your allergy symptoms by 30 percent," Bassett said.

Also important, Bassett added, is that everyone with asthma should be tested for allergies. "Certain allergies can be modified" with lifestyle changes, prevention or medication, he says. - (HealthScout News)

Read more:
Asthma Condition Centre
Allergy Condition Centre
Click here for related titles on


Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Ask the Expert

Allergy expert

Dr Morris is the Principal Allergist at the Cape Town and Johannesburg Allergy Clinics with postgraduate diplomas in Allergology, Dermatology, Paediatrics and Family Medicine dealing with both adult and childhood allergies. obesity and diabetes societies and runs a trial centre for new drugs.

Still have a question?

Get free advice from our panel of experts

The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical exmanication, diagnosis and formal advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.

* You must accept our condition

Forum Rules