21 December 2011

'27 Club' of dead rockers is a myth

Fame boosts the risk of early death for rock stars but the claim that the peril is greatest at age 27 is false, according to a study published by the British Medical Journal.


Fame boosts the risk of early death for rock stars but the claim that the peril is greatest at the age of 27 is false, according to a study published by the British Medical Journal (BMJ).

The theory of the "27 Club" spread earlier this year when Amy Winehouse joined Jim Morrison, Kurt Cobain and Brian Jones and other musicians who succumbed to the rock'n'roll lifestyle while in their 27th year.

Health statisticians led by Adrian Barnett of the Queensland University of Technology in Australia put the "27 Club" hypothesis to the test.

They compiled a data base of 1 046 musicians – solo artists and band members – who had a No 1 album in the British charts between 1956 and 2007, a net that included balladeers, pop singers, R&B and heavy metal.

Cub unlikely to be a phenomenon

The first No. 1 was Frank Sinatra's Songs for Swinging Lovers! on July 28 1956, and the last was Leona Lewis' Spirit on November 18 2007.

During the period under study, 71 of the musicians died equivalent to 7% of the sample.

But there was no peak at all in deaths at the age of 27.

On the other hand, musicians in their 20s and 30s were two to three times likelier to die prematurely than the general British population.

"The 27 Club is unlikely to be a real phenomenon," says the paper.

Fame increases the risk of death

"Fame may increase the risk of death among musicians, but this risk is not limited to age 27."

Historically, the big risk period for rock'n'roll fame appears to be the 1970s and early 80s, the researchers say.

After that, the number of deaths among the chart-toppers fell sharply. Indeed, there was a period in the late eighties when there were no mortalities at all.

Why this is so is unclear – it could be that treatment for drug overdoses and addiction improved, and thus saved musicians in danger.

The "27 Club" gained currency with Winehouse's death in July, prompting the explanation that musicians often become famous in their early twenties, and their risk-taking peaks four to five years later.

Musicians crave to be immortal

A more insidious argument was that musicians craving immortality subconsciously became bigger risk-takers, or even committed suicide, in order to join rock's dead elite.

Faithful to the principles of scientific rigour, the authors of the study acknowledge that the data trawl has some flaws.

Three of the "27 Club" (Jimi Hendrix, Janis Joplin and Jim Morrison) did not have a No. 1 album in Britain and were thus excluded.

Kermit the Frog also had a No. 1 at this time with the Muppets.

The bulgy-eyed amphibian and his chums are not known for substance abuse or playing with guns.

So in an act of statistical fairness, the study included the mortality rate among the actors who played their parts.

(Sapa, December 2011) 


Read Health24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Live healthier

PMS, depression & suicide »

Don't let PMS get you down Symptoms of PMS Diagnosing PMS

The link between PMS, depression and suicidal thoughts

The symptoms of premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD) are similar to those of PMS, but generally more severe – and could include depression and even thoughts of suicide.

A vegan marathon runner »

Comrades: don't run if you're ill Fuel your body for the Comrades

Running the Comrades Marathon on a vegan diet

Donovan Will, who is training to run the Comrades Marathon, speaks to Health24 about his plant based diet and fears of getting injured ahead of the big race.