Posted by: lerita | 2009-03-23

which puppy to buy or not to buy

I konw that this is not a discussion forum, but give me so guidance in what to buy. We had a robbery last week. Luckily I woke up and hubby and me chase the robbers away. We promised our children a dog after this insidence. Which dog is very attentive?. She has to sleep with us in the house. She also have to be disciplined as I breed with small rabbits in cages. I do not want the dog to terrorise the rabbits or break iinto their cages. I know that if a rabbit escape it will be signing its own death warrant. My children is 5 and 9 years. I though about a Jack Russell or scotty but I am not very sure. Please help!!

Not what you were looking for? Try searching again, or ask your own question
Our expert says:
Expert ImageCyberVet

Dear Lerita

Do some research on Rottweilers.

The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical exmanication, diagnosis and formal advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.

Our users say:
Posted by: niek | 2009-03-31

het ook nou ' n baby bullmastiff gekry, baie oulik, sy en my kat (3 maande) asook die 2 kinders (1 jaar &  3 jaar) speel lekker saam. het ook gehoor dis beste hond vir kinders en as waghond.

Reply to niek
Posted by: Jakes | 2009-03-26

Most puppies r cute. 2 me the boxers, bullmastiffs + boerboel puppies r the cutest of them all. But remember it will not stay a pup. It will eventually bcome an adult dog + U' ll have 2 deal with it. When buying from a breeder, a good thing is to check out the temprement of both parents. That should give U a reasonable idea of what temprement U can expect your dog 2 have.

Reply to Jakes
Posted by: Steve | 2009-03-26

I would stay away from terriers. Most terriers r not really suitable 4 children. It' s a fact, most med. + large breed female dogs r good with kids if they r bought as puppies. Also a bigger type of dog is a bigger deterent to woul b thieves + housebreakers. We have a Rottie x Ridgeback, she' s 15 &  can hardly bark anymore but the people r very scared of her. Border collies r not really suitable 4 children. Look at GSD' s, Dobies, Labradores, Boxers, Bullmastiffs + Rottweilers. I' m sure that U ' ll find something among these. Remember that pedigree dogs from reputable breeders r expensive but usually worth it in the long run.

Reply to Steve
Posted by: WR | 2009-03-24

Hi there,

The best advice I can give you is to think/ research dogs that are traditionally good family dogs, but that also get along with other animals.
If you do get a shelter dog - try and get as young a dog as possible.
You should also consider the size that you' ll be able to handle.
For a first timer I would not recommend a high energy dog like a Border Collie.
Yes, even though I am a German Shepherd lover, I still do think that it is (trying to be as objective as possible) your best option. They were originally used for flock guarding/ herding, very alert and obviously, if trained properly, great with other animals - but that will be the same for most dogs. I do agree that you should not look at any Terrier type dog - and for that matter, no sight-hounds - they are all hunters and they are difficult to ' cure' ...
Good luck!

Reply to WR
Posted by: lerita | 2009-03-24

Thanks for everybodys input. I will give the animal shelters a thought though

Reply to lerita
Posted by: Chill | 2009-03-23

Bullmastiffs are undoubtedly wonderful dogs, but hardly a breed to recommend to a ' beginner' .... they' re also damned expensive to feed!

I would tend to support the dog-shelted idea - go there with an open mind, and listen to the advice given. You will undoubtedly find something suitable there, and you' d also have the satisfaction of giving an ' unwanted'  pup/dog a home.

Reply to Chill
Posted by: Big dog lover | 2009-03-23

Bullmastiffs especially spayed females make wonderful family dogs + also good watch dogs. They' re very good with children + if the grow up with other pets then they accept them as being part of the family. Although big, they r not overly boistrous + don' t bark 4 nothing. It' s a fact - when your Bullmastiff barks then go see what or who is there. Spayed female Rottweilers from good stock also make good family dogs. They r more active than Bullmastiffs + if they grow up with your children they will always b there to protect them. Ideal situation is to have 2 large dogs - preferably spayed females together. Years ago we had a Bullmastif + a Doberman together - both females. What a good combination they were + they both loved kids.

Reply to Big dog lover
Posted by: Carol | 2009-03-23

Any of the terrier breeds are going to be a pain the butt with rabbits.

I have two boxers ...I also have ducks, chickens,geese, parrots and cats .... I have no problem whatsoever with my two dogs . They sleep in the house as thats the best place for any dog IMO

Boxers are IMO the best child dog you can get , they are medium sized wont eat you out of house and home and are loyal protective dogs.

The only problem is they tend to be extremly naughty, but them a lot of puppies are .. boxers however stay naughty ..they dont grow up.

Good luck with your search.

Reply to Carol
Posted by: Boerboel Owner | 2009-03-23

You can also go to dogbreedinfodotcom there is a lot of useful info on a lot of breeds and they have a quiz to help you choose a dog

Reply to Boerboel Owner
Posted by: Mandi | 2009-03-23

I' m not familiar with scotties, but I have JR experience and my opinion is NOT to go for the JR.
JR' s are hunting dogs and the rabbits might put the hunting instinct into overdrive. And when a JR goes into " hunting"  mode, a chicken-wire / wooden cage won' t keep her way from the rabbits.

Maybe you can go to your local shelter to see if there is a puppy which " talks"  to you?

Reply to Mandi

Have your say

Thanks for commenting! Your comment will appear on the site shortly.
Thanks for commenting! Your comment will appear on the site shortly.