advertisement
Question
Posted by: KC | 2012/09/04

Q.

Real vs Make Believe... Need help on this one!

For the last couple of months my four and a half year old son has been obsessed with superheroes. You can''t blame him, they are everywhere from toys and clothing to sweet packets. Kids talk at school etc and it seems to be the in thing at the moment. I have always been extremely strict with what my son watches and how long he is allowed to sit and watch t.v. We don''t have DSTV at home so our viewing options are very limited and controlled. Long story short, I could no longer avoid the interest my son began showing towards superheroes and the questions where to much. I decided to go out and buy him an animated DVD of superman and co and he absolutely loves it. I have sat with him and watched the episodes. Explained to him what it really means to be a hero. I will not tolerate aggressive behavior whether it be hurting another child/adult or deliberately breaking toys. Because superheroes are all my son wants to talk about I make a point on reminding him how kindness can make you a hero, I talk about police and paramedics being heroes etc, etc.
As I said at the moment, being a hero is a huge thing to my son. He admires superman and batman etc. I have let it be and let him enjoy this new big boy craze but yesterday I was crushed when I found out his teacher had told him that superheroes don''t exist.
I feel children have such a short time to believe in make believe and to live in a magical world that I really don''t see a problem in believing provided they are not going to come to harm or harm others. I have made it quite clear he does not have super powers and can never jump off a roof or similar.
I now have the dilemma do I tell him they are not real or do I let him believe for a little while longer.
I want to have a talk to his teacher but I don''t know if I making a big thing out of nothing but I really believe it is my place to say what my child should and should not believe in?
What do you think?

11
user comments
Posted by: Angie | 2012/09/13

Wow, your veiws are quiet interesting. Imagination is a powerful thing so i''d let them enjoy it while it lasts.

Reply to Angie
Posted by: Maria | 2012/09/04

Four was definitely the " easiest"  age for us... when I look at my daughter and puberty starting I sometimes really wish we could just turn back the clock for a bit.

Reply to Maria
Posted by: KC | 2012/09/04

Thanks ladies, my boy has the most amazing little imagination. He can occupy himself with lego for hours. Each character has a different voice or accent and he goes into his own little world. I love this age. He still believes in Barney and I love that he does.
Will let it be for now and see how things go.

Reply to KC
Posted by: andy | 2012/09/04

KC your boy is still young let him enjoy the superheroes for now it will pass at some point, but a 4yr old does not want to hear that ben10 or batman does not exist. My boys know they cant fly so i have to hold them up and run a few rounds with them while the pretend to fly like the superheroes. in a way they know that some things the superheroes do  only they can do on tv. my point is let him be a outjie for now who likes things other outjies like, soon he will be out of it and you have to stres about real issues like the type of music he listens to, what he watches on his phone etc.

Reply to andy
Posted by: Maria | 2012/09/04

My 10 year old was still upset quite recently when a friend told her that dragons don''t exist! I was rather surprised that she thought they do.

When she was 4 she was constantly living in a fantasy world and acting out being some character. She never watched much tv, the characters were generally animals or something else that she made up herself. It''s such a rich phase, life must be really interesting then!

Reply to Maria
Posted by: jo | 2012/09/04

I think Mother and G have pretty much summed it up, i wouldnt approach the teacher but id tell my daughter she can believe in what ever she wants to :)

Reply to jo
Posted by: G+ | 2012/09/04

My daughter is now 7 and lives in a fantasy world. she now starts to distinguish between real and make believe and has often asked me things like whether fairies really exists because the kids at school say they don''t. I tell her that every one has a fantasy world and there you can decide what is real and what not. In your fantasy world anything can come to life.

Reply to G+
Posted by: Mother | 2012/09/04

I''d be wary of approaching the teacher, KC. I''d probably tell kiddo that " Well, maybe the teacher''s never seen any superhero! Poor her." 
My son''s crazy about super-heroes too. But this morning he says " I hate Dragon Ballz, I don''t wanna see it again, it''s just like wrestling"  Hehe, and mommy hates wrestling, so I say " Yes, they''re all rubbish"  and he agreed! This from a boy who whines when I don''t fetch him from school earlier ''cos then he misses Dragonballz!

Reply to Mother
Posted by: KC | 2012/09/04

The first thing that sprang to mind was Santa! I want my kids to have as much magic as possible because by the time they hit big school it really all flies out the window.
Would you ladies chat to the teacher and ask her nicely to stop telling him superman does not exist?

Reply to KC
Posted by: jo | 2012/09/04

I dont think there is anything wrong with him believing that there is a super hero out there.

My nephew has the same obssesion he loves superheros, id say let him hold onto his fantasy.

I am not sure how to tackle the teacher though, does she also tell him that santa isnt real? If she is of a certain religeon does she force her views on the kids and say their god is not real? I think thats a bit wrong of the teacher to do that. Peoples personal opinions shouldnt be forced on another person. That goes for everything.

Reply to jo
Posted by: Maria | 2012/09/04

Jeez, is she also going to tell him Father Christmas and the tooth fairy are not real. I quite agree with your feelings on the subject.

Reply to Maria

Want to comment?

Thanks for commenting! Your comment will appear on the site shortly.
Thanks for commenting! Your comment will appear on the site shortly.
advertisement