Our expert says:
There are some excellent oncologists, but ome seem extraordinarily clumsy as regards basic people skills. Often they are competent at treating the cancer, less so at treating the person with the cancer.
There's usually no harm in a second opinion, as it seems reasonable that your family has some problems in having full confidence in this oncologist. The issue is WHY one wants such an opinion and would it really benefit your aunt.
Do you as a group feel that he has been a bit careless in respecting her feelings ( which would sound like it's a fair assessment ) ? Or does one really have grounds for suspecting that her condition is less grave than he has concluded - or that different treatment would genuinely make a real difference to the length and quality of her life ? Maybe not the second, which might be better grounds for persuading her to go for a second opinion.
My concern would be that if there's no realistic chance of a better outcome from changing oncologists, there's some risk of damaging her confidence, and engendering regrets that she might have made the wrong decisions, which would not be any benefit at this stage of her illness.
One needs to discuss the isues with her sister to help her see that what matters is what is best for the aunt herself - too easily we get trapped into demanding different and more aggressive treatments for her to meet OUR needs, and not hers. A counsellor may help if necessary.
For the aunt, one needs to gently chat with her, to understand how she sees her situation and what she wants for herself. The Cancer Association should be able to advise, ascould her nearest Hospice, as to teratment more focussed on preserving her comfort and quality of life for as long as possible. The less one can expect quantity of life, the more important it is to focus on quality.
Cat says Thanks
The information provided does not constitute a diagnosis of your condition. You should consult a medical practitioner or other appropriate health care professional for a physical exmanication, diagnosis and formal
advice. Health24 and the expert accept no responsibility or liability for any damage or personal harm you may suffer resulting from making use of this content.